helm2からhelm3に(削除履歴も含めて)マイグレーションできるのか試してみた

はじめに

本記事では，helm3のリリースに伴い，helm2からhelm３へのマイグレーションを検証した記事になります．

マイグレーションのやり方については公式マイグレーション チュートリアルに掲載されているのですが，
この記事ではhelm2でDEPLOYED以外の履歴もhelm3に受け継がれるのか気になったので試してみたいと思います．

※結論から言うと，

• helm3にはdeletedのみリスト表示するオプションが消えておりDELETEDなどは受け継がれない
• helm listで表示され方がnamespaceごとに変わった

ようでした．

環境

今回，検証にGKE使用を使用しました

• k8s cluster
  • GKE v1.13.11-gke.14

またhelm2であらかじめ下記をデプロイしておきました

• helm2でデプロイされたもの
  • cert-manager
  • hackmd
  • nginx-ingress(デプロイ後に削除済み)
  • tiller(helm2のコンポーネント)

helm list -a の結果はこんな感じ．
nginx-ingressが削除された履歴も残っています．

$ helm list -a
NAME            REVISION        UPDATED                         STATUS          CHART                   APP VERSION     NAMESPACE
cert-manager    1               Thu Nov 21 13:50:37 2019        DEPLOYED        cert-manager-v0.11.0    v0.11.0         cert-manager
hackmd          1               Thu Nov 21 13:44:16 2019        DEPLOYED        hackmd-1.2.1            1.3.0-alpine    default
nginx-ingress   1               Thu Nov 21 13:48:46 2019        DELETED         nginx-ingress-1.24.4    0.26.1          default

helm3とマイグレ用プラグインの導入

wget https://get.helm.sh/helm-v3.0.0-darwin-amd64.tar.gz
tar xzf helm-v3.0.0-darwin-amd64.tar.gz
cd darwin-amd64/
mv helm helm3 # 説明上helmバージョンが分かりにくくなるので明示的にhelm3 とリネームしてます．

helm 2 to 3というマイグレーション用プラグインが提供されているのでそちらを入れてみる

./helm3 plugin install https://github.com/helm/helm-2to3

入っているか確認．

./helm3 plugin list
NAME	VERSION	DESCRIPTION
2to3	0.2.0  	migrate and cleanup Helm v2 configuration and releases in-place to Helm v3

このプラグインでは，

• 構成の移行
• リリースの移行
• 構成のクリーンアップ
• etc

ができるらしい．

./helm3 2to3
Migrate and Cleanup Helm v2 configuration and releases in-place to Helm v3

Usage:
  2to3 [command]

Available Commands:
  cleanup     cleanup Helm v2 configuration, release data and Tiller deployment
  convert     migrate Helm v2 release in-place to Helm v3
  help        Help about any command
  move        migrate Helm v2 configuration in-place to Helm v3

Flags:
  -h, --help   help for 2to3

Use "2to3 [command] --help" for more information about a command.

マイグレーション実行!

cert-manager, hackmd, nginx-ingress(削除済み)をそれぞれhelm3に移行していきます．

$ helm3 2to3 convert cert-manager
2019/12/08 14:44:35 Release "cert-manager" will be converted from Helm v2 to Helm v3.
2019/12/08 14:44:35 [Helm 3] Release "cert-manager" will be created.
2019/12/08 14:44:36 [Helm 3] ReleaseVersion "cert-manager.v1" will be created.
2019/12/08 14:44:37 [Helm 3] ReleaseVersion "cert-manager.v1" created.
2019/12/08 14:44:37 [Helm 3] Release "cert-manager" created.
2019/12/08 14:44:37 Release "cert-manager" was converted successfully from Helm v2 to Helm v3.
2019/12/08 14:44:37 Note: The v2 release information still remains and should be removed to avoid conflicts with the migrated v3 release.
2019/12/08 14:44:37 v2 release information should only be removed using `helm 2to3` cleanup and when all releases have been migrated over.

$ helm3 2to3 convert  hackmd
2019/12/08 14:44:45 Release "hackmd" will be converted from Helm v2 to Helm v3.
2019/12/08 14:44:45 [Helm 3] Release "hackmd" will be created.
2019/12/08 14:44:45 [Helm 3] ReleaseVersion "hackmd.v1" will be created.
2019/12/08 14:44:47 [Helm 3] ReleaseVersion "hackmd.v1" created.
2019/12/08 14:44:47 [Helm 3] Release "hackmd" created.
2019/12/08 14:44:47 Release "hackmd" was converted successfully from Helm v2 to Helm v3.
2019/12/08 14:44:47 Note: The v2 release information still remains and should be removed to avoid conflicts with the migrated v3 release.
2019/12/08 14:44:47 v2 release information should only be removed using `helm 2to3` cleanup and when all releases have been migrated over.

$ helm3 2to3 convert nginx-ingress
2019/12/08 14:44:52 Release "nginx-ingress" will be converted from Helm v2 to Helm v3.
2019/12/08 14:44:52 [Helm 3] Release "nginx-ingress" will be created.
2019/12/08 14:44:53 [Helm 3] ReleaseVersion "nginx-ingress.v1" will be created.
2019/12/08 14:44:54 [Helm 3] ReleaseVersion "nginx-ingress.v1" created.
2019/12/08 14:44:54 [Helm 3] Release "nginx-ingress" created.
2019/12/08 14:44:54 Release "nginx-ingress" was converted successfully from Helm v2 to Helm v3.
2019/12/08 14:44:54 Note: The v2 release information still remains and should be removed to avoid conflicts with the migrated v3 release.
2019/12/08 14:44:54 v2 release information should only be removed using `helm 2to3` cleanup and when all releases have been migrated over.

エラーなくマイグレーション処理できたようです．

マイグレーション結果の確認

それでは，helm2でデプロイされたものがhelm3に引き継がれているかhelm list確認しましょう．

$ helm3 list
NAME  	NAMESPACE	REVISION	UPDATED                               	STATUS  	CHART       	APP VERSION
hackmd	default  	1       	2019-11-21 04:44:16.01041787 +0000 UTC	deployed	hackmd-1.2.1	1.3.0-alpine

あれ，cert-manager nginx-ingress が消えた!?

$ helm3 list --all-namespaces
NAME        	NAMESPACE   	REVISION	UPDATED                                	STATUS  	CHART               	APP VERSION
cert-manager	cert-manager	1       	2019-11-21 04:50:37.881040911 +0000 UTC	deployed	cert-manager-v0.11.0	v0.11.0
hackmd      	default     	1       	2019-11-21 04:44:16.01041787 +0000 UTC 	deployed	hackmd-1.2.1        	1.3.0-alpine

どうやら， helm list の挙動がデフォルトで全namespace表示だったところ, namespaceごとに表示範囲が変わったようです．

また，helm2で削除した履歴(nginx-ingress)は残っていないようでした．
そもそも，helm3のlistコマンドにDELETEDのみを表示するオプションが消えていました．

$ helm3 list -h

~~~~~~~省略~~~~~~~~

Flags:
  -a, --all              show all releases, not just the ones marked deployed or failed
      --all-namespaces   list releases across all namespaces
  -d, --date             sort by release date
      --deployed         show deployed releases. If no other is specified, this will be automatically enabled
      --failed           show failed releases
~~~~~~~省略~~~~~~~~

clean up

最後にhelm2のリリース情報やhelm3から不要になったTillerコンポーネントなどを削除して終わりたいと思います．

$ helm3 2to3 cleanup
WARNING: "Helm v2 Configuration" "Release Data" "Release Data" will be removed.
This will clean up all releases managed by Helm v2. It will not be possible to restore them if you haven't made a backup of the releases.
Helm v2 may not be usable afterwards.

[Cleanup/confirm] Are you sure you want to cleanup Helm v2 data? [y/N]: y
2019/12/08 14:59:47
Helm v2 data will be cleaned up.
2019/12/08 14:59:47 [Helm 2] Releases will be deleted.
2019/12/08 14:59:48 [Helm 2] ReleaseVersion "cert-manager.v1" will be deleted.
2019/12/08 14:59:49 [Helm 2] ReleaseVersion "cert-manager.v1" deleted.
2019/12/08 14:59:49 [Helm 2] ReleaseVersion "hackmd.v1" will be deleted.
2019/12/08 14:59:49 [Helm 2] ReleaseVersion "hackmd.v1" deleted.
2019/12/08 14:59:49 [Helm 2] ReleaseVersion "xrayed-rabbit.v1" will be deleted.
2019/12/08 14:59:49 [Helm 2] ReleaseVersion "xrayed-rabbit.v1" deleted.
2019/12/08 14:59:49 [Helm 2] Releases deleted.
2019/12/08 14:59:49 [Helm 2] Tiller in "kube-system" namespace will be removed.
2019/12/08 14:59:49 [Helm 2] Tiller "deploy" in "kube-system" namespace will be removed.
2019/12/08 14:59:52 [Helm 2] Tiller "deploy" in "kube-system" namespace was removed successfully.
2019/12/08 14:59:52 [Helm 2] Tiller "service" in "kube-system" namespace will be removed.
2019/12/08 14:59:53 [Helm 2] Tiller "service" in "kube-system" namespace was removed successfully.
2019/12/08 14:59:53 [Helm 2] Tiller in "kube-system" namespace was removed.
2019/12/08 14:59:53 [Helm 2] Home folder "/Users/kaz/.helm" will be deleted.
2019/12/08 14:59:53 [Helm 2] Home folder "/Users/kaz/.helm" deleted.
2019/12/08 14:59:53 Helm v2 data was cleaned up successfully.
%

以上の処理が完了すると(helm2での)helm listやTillerコンポーネントが消えたことが確認できました

helm list
Error: could not find tiller

おわりに

• helm3ではDELETEDのみリスト表示するオプションが無くなった
• helm2 -> helm3移行でDELETEDは引き継がれない
• helm listで表示され方がnamespaceごとに変わった

deleteの履歴がマイグレーションで引き継がれないことによる弊害は考えにくいですが，
履歴が必要そうな人は気をつけたほうが良いかもしれませんね!