Your liquidity pool withdrawal returned a different mix because trades changed the pool’s reserves as prices moved: you received more of the token that fell relative to its partner and less of the one that rose. On shiba swap, classic Dig pools make this visible because an LP token tracks a share of the pool’s current reserves. Arbitrage traders buy whichever token is cheaper in the pool until its price moves close to the wider market price.
Your LP Token Tracks Reserves, So the Mix Changes
An LP token represents your percentage share of a liquidity pool’s changing reserves, so redeeming it returns the current token mix. The different mix is what you receive; impermanent loss is the separate measure of how much less that mix is worth than simply holding the two tokens you deposited. It is a comparison with holding, not necessarily a fall in your position’s dollar value.
A classic pool starts with two tokens deposited at equal value. Its pricing rule keeps the product of the token reserves, x × y = k, constant as trades move tokens in and out, apart from the effect of fees. When one token rises on the wider market, traders buy it from the pool and add the other token. The pool ends up with less of the rising token and more of its partner.
- Deposit: You supply equal values of two tokens and receive LP tokens for your share of the pool.
- Trading: Swaps shift the reserves. Arbitrage brings the pool price back toward the market price by buying the cheaper token from the pool.
- Withdrawal: You redeem your share of the reserves as they stand then, including your share of fees earned in the pool.
Take a simplified pool you own entirely. You deposit 1 ETH worth $100 and 100 USDC worth $100. Later, ETH doubles to $200 while USDC stays at $1. Ignoring fees, arbitrage leaves the pool with about 0.707 ETH and 141.42 USDC. Those amounts still multiply to roughly 100, and at the new price each side is worth about $141.42.
Withdrawing gives you about $282.84 in total. Holding your original 1 ETH and 100 USDC would give you $300. The $17.16 gap is about 5.7% of the holding value. Your pooled position gained value from its $200 starting point; it simply gained less than holding would have. The example scales to a smaller pool share because both the pooled value and holding value scale together.
You can estimate that gap from the price change alone. Let r = new price ratio ÷ starting price ratio, using the same quote for one token in units of the other at both times. For a classic, full-range, equal-value constant-product position, impermanent loss = 2√r ÷ (1 + r) − 1. The result is a fraction of what your original tokens would be worth if held, before fees; multiply by 100 for a percentage. Here r = $200 per ETH ÷ $100 per ETH = 2, so 2√2 ÷ 3 − 1 ≈ −0.057, or −5.7%. A 4× price ratio gives −20%.
That estimate helps when choosing a future pool. Tokens whose prices tend to move together produce a smaller gap; volatile pairs can produce a larger one. Trading fees can offset or even exceed impermanent loss, but fee income depends on trading activity and your share of it. For a new provider, compare the likely relative price movement with fees you can reasonably expect. The formula describes classic pools like Uniswap v2 and ShibaSwap v1 Dig pools; Shiba Inu’s pool documentation distinguishes those LP-token positions from v2 concentrated positions, whose results depend on the chosen price range.
Related Questions
Is impermanent loss permanent?
Impermanent loss becomes a realized shortfall against holding when you withdraw while the relative price has changed. While your liquidity remains in the pool, a return toward the starting price can shrink that gap. Once you withdraw, your token amounts are fixed unless you trade again. Fees already earned still count toward your actual result, so compare the value of the withdrawn tokens plus fees with the value of holding the original pair.
Which pools have the least impermanent loss?
Classic pools whose two tokens stay close in relative price generally have the least impermanent loss. A pair of stablecoins can fit that pattern while both maintain their pegs; a peg breaking changes the calculation quickly. The key input is how one token moves against the other, not whether both rise or fall against dollars. Use the price ratio in the formula to compare candidate pairs under a move you consider plausible.
How do I withdraw liquidity on shiba swap?
For a classic Dig position, connect the wallet on the correct network, find your v1 liquidity position, choose Remove Liquidity, and review the displayed amounts of both tokens before confirming. If your LP tokens are staked in Woof, withdraw them from there first so they are available to redeem. A v2 position uses Decrease Liquidity instead. Before confirming, calculate the holding comparison with today’s price ratio; that tells you what the changed mix has cost or gained relative to keeping the original tokens.