At first AI coding felt magical.
Then my repo hit 40+ files.
Windsurf was still useful for:
- rough structure
- brainstorming
- fast UI iteration
But Codex became much stronger when:
- files started connecting together
- refactoring affected multiple modules
- cleanup became more important than prototyping
My workflow now is usually:
Windsurf -> rough prototype
Codex -> repo-wide cleanup/refactor
Manual testing -> rollback if needed
The larger the repo became, the more context management mattered.